Homemade American Cheese | Tasty
Homemade American cheese is easier than you'd think, and way more satisfying than the store-bought stuff. You only need two kinds of cheddar, whole milk, and a couple of food-science ingredients (sodium citrate and gelatin) to get that perfectly creamy, melt-in-your-mouth texture we all grew up on. The process takes just about 25 minutes of active time, then the cheese sets in the fridge until sliceable and ready to layer on burgers, grilled cheese, or anything that deserves a melty moment. Make a batch on the weekend as a fun project, and you'll have a stack of homemade slices ready to go all week.